Friday, 21 October 2011

chapter 5-7, is stoker confused or simply mad?

Yet again I've been left feeling very disappointed by Stoker after the next section of Dracula. The novel has a really confused structure involving all sorts of genres which really makes it hard for me to enjoy the novel! Chapters 5-7 explain the various love lives of Mina Murray and Lucy Westenra. Bram Stoker spends so much time trying to inflict an element of realism that the novel just becomes so, so tiresome.

As if have already discussed in my blog, I find the book incredibly fanatical and unrealistic due to the contrived nature of elements of the first chapter. However after the real fantasy of the first four chapters, Stoker tries to make the novel more realistic by giving us endless details that are incredibly tiresome and seem completely irrelevant. For example we find out that Mina is desperate to start writing. Good for her but do we really care? No is my answer. Its just so trivial! I can understand why Stoker has tried to do this because it adds to the realism but when the first few chapters are so contrived it has probably lost its realistic element. To add to this there is a fine balance between being realistic and being dull. Unfortunately I don’t think Stoker quite pulls this off as I often had to stop myself nodding off when trailing through the huge great passages of descriptive but not informative information.

There were a few positive things from the section, for example I enjoyed reading about the patient in the Asylum because it wasn’t supernatural and much less contrived than the rest of the novel. The element of not knowing the mans potential danger had me gripped and excited also the fact that Seward simply has no idea what to do about his patient surprises me but further adds to his danger. I also thought that the particular extract regarding the Asylum shows Stokers capabilities as a horror writer. I thought the description of what the man was doing with the food chain setup was rather disturbing but at the same time brilliant because it was everything that I had expected Dracula to be.

Unfortunately the consistency or lack of consistency in this section once again made it much less enjoyable than it could have been. This switching between the horror and the gothic to the desperate romantics disrupted the cohesion of the novel. To conclude, I think Stoker really should stick to his strengths as a brilliant horror writer and steer away from the supernatural influences and romantic sub stories. He may have been trying to make the novel more appropriate so that it would be allowed to publish but it still tarnishes what could have been a great section.

No comments:

Post a Comment