Thursday, 27 October 2011

8-9, is a little bit of optimism possible?

Writing blogs has never been regarded as the most exciting way to spend an afternoon, and unsurprisingly this gloomy autumnal day is no exception. However because I just purchased a new bobble hat for the winter (which i am wearing at the moment) I’m in rather jovial spirits. Also I fear for the reputation of my magnificent blog so will attempt to write about Dracula positively... wish me luck.

For those of you who have spent some of your quality free time reading my not overly exciting, but still very high quality blog, I sympathise. I recognise that I've been rather negative, so with my bobble hat I set off reading Dracula a tad more optimistically and positively.

Fortunately I was in luck, as chapter 9 finally gives us something to smile about (for the sake of positivity I shall ignore chapter 8 as it slightly damaged my optimism). Johnny Harker's back! Wehey! Yay! Woohoo! You may also notice how I've slightly changed my opinion of Harker. I think I prefer him when he's weak and vulnerable because he's acting like less of an idiot! Finally!

Now is the point in the blog where I loose any masculinity I had remaining after the bobble hat confession. I actually thought this chapter was really sweet :’) SO ROMANTIC! Getting married by the lovely sisters in the novel and then sealing the diary, its strange how something as small as that can be so significant and really illustrates the curiosity of the human mind.

Unfortunately though the whole chapter is not set in Prague and we have to continue with the stories of the other characters. I think it’s cute also that Doctor Seward is still caring this much for Lucy despite her rejecting his proposal. He is either a true gent, or so, so desperate! Either way this Lucy girl must be rather special, especially if a doctor from Holland is willing to come all the way to England to care for her!

Well that wasn’t very exciting but much more enjoyable considering the bobble hat. Overall I think this chapter was rather lovely but under the bobble I’m rather confused! Isn’t this supposed to be dark, gothic, scary? Stoker confuses me, ah well at least I have my hat J

Friday, 21 October 2011

chapter 5-7, is stoker confused or simply mad?

Yet again I've been left feeling very disappointed by Stoker after the next section of Dracula. The novel has a really confused structure involving all sorts of genres which really makes it hard for me to enjoy the novel! Chapters 5-7 explain the various love lives of Mina Murray and Lucy Westenra. Bram Stoker spends so much time trying to inflict an element of realism that the novel just becomes so, so tiresome.

As if have already discussed in my blog, I find the book incredibly fanatical and unrealistic due to the contrived nature of elements of the first chapter. However after the real fantasy of the first four chapters, Stoker tries to make the novel more realistic by giving us endless details that are incredibly tiresome and seem completely irrelevant. For example we find out that Mina is desperate to start writing. Good for her but do we really care? No is my answer. Its just so trivial! I can understand why Stoker has tried to do this because it adds to the realism but when the first few chapters are so contrived it has probably lost its realistic element. To add to this there is a fine balance between being realistic and being dull. Unfortunately I don’t think Stoker quite pulls this off as I often had to stop myself nodding off when trailing through the huge great passages of descriptive but not informative information.

There were a few positive things from the section, for example I enjoyed reading about the patient in the Asylum because it wasn’t supernatural and much less contrived than the rest of the novel. The element of not knowing the mans potential danger had me gripped and excited also the fact that Seward simply has no idea what to do about his patient surprises me but further adds to his danger. I also thought that the particular extract regarding the Asylum shows Stokers capabilities as a horror writer. I thought the description of what the man was doing with the food chain setup was rather disturbing but at the same time brilliant because it was everything that I had expected Dracula to be.

Unfortunately the consistency or lack of consistency in this section once again made it much less enjoyable than it could have been. This switching between the horror and the gothic to the desperate romantics disrupted the cohesion of the novel. To conclude, I think Stoker really should stick to his strengths as a brilliant horror writer and steer away from the supernatural influences and romantic sub stories. He may have been trying to make the novel more appropriate so that it would be allowed to publish but it still tarnishes what could have been a great section.

Thursday, 13 October 2011

Critics interpretations

If you read my first blog, you'll have noticed that I found the character Jonothan Harker quite annoying. As i mentioned at the time of my last post I assumed this would be due to the barrier in time between the audience at the time of publication and modern audiences. However I tried to think of it from the perspective of a 19th century audience and still found it impossible to relate to.

So after this I decided to a bit of digging to see what contemporary critics felt about the novel as a whole and in particular about Harker himself. Unfortunately this was much easier said than done. Although google produced millions of results I couldn’t find anything directly on Harker and the reviews I did find were very brief.

The ones I did find though provided a very interesting outlook. I was unsurprised to find that many critics were horrified by the content of Dracula, because even I was horrified reading some sections of the first 4 chapters and I come from a culture where I have grown up around graphic horror films such as the Saw saga and other works such as Final Destination. I was however surprised about how compelling critics found the story. For example Bookman gives this summary, “in the course of the tale we hurried over things with repulsion, we read nearly the whole thing with rapt attention” however after the first 4 chapters I had already lost almost all motivation to read on due to the fact I found Harker so impossible to relate to, and the contrived nature of the first 4 chapters.  

Thursday, 6 October 2011

Chapter 1-4 - Looks like harkers in a spot of bother...

Having read the first 4 chapters of Dracula I have to say that Mr Harker seems to have got himself in a spot of bother. Imprisoned in a Castle with nobody but a blood drinking, human eating, lizard like maniac isn't the best thing to happen to you. Part of me says I should feel sorry for Harker, but in my opinion he only has himself to blame. I don’t think many people would choose to spend over a month in a Transylvanian castle with a person they had never met, especially when all the locals try to tell you he’s a nutter! I’d run a mile!

Not only does Harker seem incredibly stupid to me, but I think he is also incredibly brave; I probably would have bottled it and jumped out the window by now, but things would never be so simple for John Harker! If someone wanted to kill me and drink my blood I doubt I’d be sneaking into his room, let alone searching his pockets whilst he lay there fast asleep! Also I think he’s incredibly brave in the way that he talks to the count; staying calm and not giving away any reason for the Count to suspect him.

Despite all this though, I really do struggle to sympathise with Harker as a character. Obviously I want him to escape however I just find him impossible to relate to. I think any normal person would react extremely differently to the way he does. I wouldn’t mind so much if it Stocker was trying to portray him as a fantasy heroine but he tries to present him as a normal person which I simply find ridiculous, it may just be the gap in time but I still cant imagine anyone relating to Harker. This makes me think the whole structure of the novel is flawed and confused which is a great shame considering the amazing, almost perfect villain that Stoker has created.